Polemic with Bishop Fabian Bruskewitz on
We Resist You to the Face
Brief Chronicle of Events|
Presuppositions and context to the story
Bishop Bruskewitz writes a preface disparaging Resistance
June 22, 2000: The Bishop's Preface - The weekly The Wanderer published the first of seven articles by Mr. Stephen Hand. The series was supposed to be a refutation of the public statement We Resist You to the Face by Mr. Atila S. Guimarães, Mr. Michael J. Matt, Mr. John Vennari and Dr. Marian T. Horvat. The statement by the four authors was published first in The Remnant (April 30, 2000), later in book form by TIA (May, 2000), and finally in the Catholic Family News (July, 2000). Mr. Hand’s first article was preceded by words from The Wanderer editor Mr. Alphonse J. Matt Jr., and a preface by His Excellency Bishop Fabian W. Bruskewitz of Lincoln.
Authors of the statement We Resist You To the Face respond
July 31, 2000: A Letter to Bishop Bruskewitz - Jonathan Tuttle questions Msgr. Bruskewitz's defense of scandalous papal actions and challenges the bishops endorsement of the controversial Stephen Hand.
September 15, 2000: Five Questions for Msgr. Bruskewitz - Atila Sinke Guimarães responds to the preface of Bishop Bruskewitz with five questions undermining his attack, pointing out flaws in his position, and questioning his double standards.
September 15, 2000: Insinuations - Dr. Marian Horvat questions Bishop Bruskewitz on the insinuations in his preface, and defends her signing of the statement We Resist You To the Face
An apology from Stephen Hand
January 30, 2008: An Apology - Stephen hand recognizes the error of his previous position and offers apologies to Atila Guimarães and Marian Horvat
Articles in the Polemic
Presuppositions and context of the controversy
The Bishop's Preface
Bishop Fabian W. Bruskewitz
Anecdotes, Trajectories & Headaches: A Letter to Bishop Bruskewitz
Five Questions for Msgr. Bruskewitz
Atila Sinke Guimarães
His Excellency's Insinuations
Marian Therese Horvat, Ph.D.
An Apology to Atila Guimarães and
Polemics | Home | News | Books | CDs | Search | Contact Us
Tradition in Action, Inc. All Rights Reserved