What People Are Commenting

donate Books CDs HOME updates search contact

Theology of Freedom & Women-Bishops

Relabeling Liberation Theology

Dear TIA,

We should have expected this treachery. Now that the masses have been mesmerized by the idea of 'religious freedom' for all, it would seem the perfect time for a 'theology of freedom' (better known to Traditional Counter Revolutionaries as 'liberation theology')

Googling "theology of freedom" brings you to libertarianism, Martin Luther and Karl Barth (a theologian I read about, hailed by Pius XII). Whereas the wikipedia definition of Liberation Theology is more damaging as it includes the many criticisms of it and actions taken against it by John Paul II and Cardinal Ratzinger over the years.

Not calling a spade a spade in this instance will lead many to think this must be good and they will automatically support it.

The following is an excerpt from an article on the Vatican Insider website:

Some have noticed similarities with the thinking of Karl Rahner in Müller’s theological work (Lehmann had worked with Rahner). In the months when the Pope was considering Müller‘s candidacy, the latter‘s link with one of the fathers of the Theology of Freedom, Fr. Gustavo Gutierrez, whose texts were closely examined by the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith (which at the time was headed by Cardinal Ratzinger) with no sentence or sanction being imposed. The new Prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith experienced Church life first hand by going to Latin America and spending some time living with the farmers in a parish near Lake Titicaca, on the border with Bolivia.

May TIA remain in the protection of the Sacred Heart of Jesus and her Immaculate Heart.


Concessions to Women-Bishops


Checking the Anglican meeting that is deciding now to approve women-bishops, I found this photo and comment from two years ago on the Bishop Kevin Boland of Valdosta, Georgia, who was attending an installation presided over by a woman-bishop right here in the U.S.

a Bishop with a woman priest

Bishop Boland participated in the installation of Scott Benhase as bishop of the Episcopal Diocese of Georgia, [presided over by female bishop Katherine Schorl]. This appalling decision illustrates once more that Bishop Boland is a wolf in sheep's clothing. Like the Catholic bishops of 16th century England, he betrays the faith in favor of "ecumenical dialogue" with material heretics who choose secular relativism over biblical truth. For more about Bishop Boland's scandal affirming the election and installation of a bishop who blesses same-sex relationships and approves the ordination of active gays like Gene Robinson, go here. Don't miss the outlandish photo of the presiding female bishop.


Israel Rounds up African Migrants for Deportation

Dear TIA,

Salve Maria!

Have you seen these news reports? The interest of preserving national character has been severely criticized in Spain's history in the 16th century, but here it is today used by its most outspoken critics.

     In Maria,


Errors Made on Purpose


The resources used for this information are unreliable, which is the reason why I hesitate to send it on. I would like, if possible, for you to send this information to L.M.G. who recently requested additional information about the Third Secret on your site.

On June 17, 2011 the Franciscan Capuchins group posted a claim that they are the "protectors" of the other copy of Sister Lucy's Third Secret. Their photo can be found here. The picture shows one of persons showing a hidden hand sign revealing that they are Masonic.

If this is true, then it provides more evidence for Atila Guimaraes' theory that the secret was tampered with. It has always been hard for me to believe such a well written documented letter could have such glaring errors, indicated to me the strong possibility that those errors were made on purpose.


Our Lady of Aparecida

Dear Sirs,

I have a friend of mine that is not in good health that is looking for a Statue of the Lady of Aparecida to put next to the portrait of his wife, who died a couple of years ago.

Do you know where would it be possible to obtain one, to satisfy this great gentleman.



TIA responds:

Dear M.S.,

We are posting this picture for you here, which you may download, print and frame for your purpose.

For more pictures, you may find one among the many here or here.


     TIA correspondent desk


Scorning the Woman Bus Monitor

Dear TIA,

I am not sure if you are familiar with the story regarding the bus monitor who was bullied by students in Rochester, NY.

What I find rather curious is the media handling of the event, as well as the Facebook response to the incident. While there is an outrage, and even an outrage due to the fact that the bus monitor is elderly, there hasn't been discussion regarding the incident as a violation against an adult's authority. People have treated this in a rather egalitarian way, treating the bus monitor, Karen Klein, as if she were another child who was bullied. There has been an outpouring of emotional, sentimental support, but nothing really of support for her authority that was violated

The real outrage to me is the fact that the children, by treating Ms. Klein in this way, showed their contempt for her authority. This is a dangerous situation. It the children don't have respect for the people put in place to ensure their safety and well-being, then no child is safe. The bus driver and Ms. Klein needed to be able to restore order, to reassert the natural hierarchy of adults over children, and to ensure the other children's safety.

The Facebook support page is here.

I find this approach rather wrong-headed, and suspect that it may have to do with the media's political motives of focusing on bullying as a new social problem.

     Yours truly,


Denying Dogma


‘Theologian Denies Dogma on PBS News Hour - Whew! This speaks volumes that Fordham theologian Jeannie Hill Fletchershe invoked Vatican II in denying the thrice infallibly defined dogma of "No Salvation outside the Church."



Blason de Charlemagne
Follow us

Posted July 10, 2012

The opinions expressed in this section - What People Are Commenting - do not necessarily express those of TIA