What People Are Asking

Tradition In Action

Fatima, Sister Lucy


Basilica of Fatima 


catholicHow Will the Dogma of Faith Remain in Portugal?
Among the little people who don't care about Progressivism


catholicIs the Dogma of the Faith Really Preserved in Portugal?
Yes, in a certain sense is


catholicWhat Is Special About Portugal?
It has a vocation of fidelity, independent of the Clergy


catholicCould the Miracle of the Sun Be Diabolical?
It was not a subjective impression, 70,000 persons witnessed it


catholicIs a Great Chastisement to Come before the Reign of Mary?
Yes, since Russia was not consecrated & immorality sky-rocked


catholicWas the Date '1960' Ordered by Our Lady?
Yes, it was; check here


catholicCan You Comment on the 2nd Interview with Fr. Malachi Martin?
Yes, here is what we have to say


catholicDid You Read Fatima Shock & Celestial Secrets to Discredit Our Lady?
We did not, but we found good book reviews of them here & here



Two Sister Lucys

catholicCan't You See that these Two Women - Celina & Lucy II - Are Different?
We based ourselves on Inside the Vatican magazine, which was mistaken


catholicCan You Check Whether that Photo of Celina Is Lucy II When Young?
They are not the same person since they appear together in a photo


catholicHas Anyone Asked the Vatican about Sister Lucy II?
The Vatican ordered the change; it would be not pleased to ackowledge it


catholicDid Fr. Malachi Martin Tell You Anything about the Two Sister Lucys?
No, he did not


catholicDid Sister Lucy's Family See the Difference?
The rule of the contemplative nuns didn't allow relatives to come close to her


catholicWhy Didn't Her Relatives Complain When She Finally Appeared in Public?
She started to appear in public after the relatives, who knew her before, died


catholicCan You Refute Mr. Grasmeier's Accusations against TIA?
Yes, we can; here is the refutation


catholicHow Long Was the Imposter Impersonating Sister Lucy?
Most likely we will only know this at the Final Judgment


catholicWhy Not Make a DNA Test to Prove the Two Lucys Thesis?
These tests would rely on the Vatican & the Convent; they will not help


catholicCan We Get Forensics on the Two Lucys?
We prefer the common sense of Catholics; experts will be under strong pressure


catholicCould You Make an Age Progression on Photos of Lucy?
Yes, but we need good photos; please, send them to us


catholicDid You Photoshop the Photos of Sr. Lucy?
The photos are unchanged from their original sources


catholicCan You Make an Age Enhancement Study of Sister Lucy I & II?
Something like this was made here


catholicDo You Still Believe Lucy Died in 1949?
No, your observation on Fr. Fuentes' 1957 interview changed our opinion



'Third Secret' Controversy

catholicWhat Is Your Source for the 3rd Secret TIA Published?
An unidentified man from Galicia, who changed constantly of e-mail & name


catholicWhy the Photographer Remains Anonymous?
Can be for lack of means or lack of courage to face the Church structure


catholicWas Your 3rd Secret Written in Dialect?
It is a current Portuguese with one expression that can be a mistake or dialect


catholicThe Paper Was Not Folded, So It Is Not the Real Secret, Right?
There were two copies of the secret; the second could be non-folded


catholic Do You Believe in a Forensic Analysis on this Case?
Without having the originals of her writings, forensic can be fooled by Photoshop


catholicDoes Your 3rd Secret Say 'The Faith Will Be Conserved in Portugal'?
It says something similar


catholicCan You Prove the Cornerstone of St. Peter's Tomb Moved to Fatima?
Yes, here is a photo of John Paul II givng it to the Rector of Fatima Sanctuary


catholicWhat about the 69 Weeks for the Chastisement to Come?
We should not rely on human calculations, but be prepared for it at any time


catholic Is Abortion One of the Great Chastisements of Our Day?
Abortion is inflicted by man; the chastisement by God


catholicWho Said the Pope Has Devilish Eyes?
It is attributed to Sister Lucy in this document


catholicJohn XXIII Did Not Have Evil Eyes, How Do You Explain It?
'Devilish eyes' could be a symbol of an evil conception of the Papacy


catholicHow Could Our Lady Mention John Paul II? It Is Impossible
In the 2nd message, she mentined Pius XI, when he was not a Pope yet


catholicHow to Explain that Juan Pablo II Is in Spanish?
It can be a shortcoming of Sr. Lucy,  who was living in Spain


catholicCan You Explain What 'Ugly Church' Means in the 3rd Secret?
'Ugly Church' could be a symbol of an entire new religion that was coming


catholicDid Pius XII Tell Card. Ottaviani to Reseal the Secret?
As far as we know this order was given by John XXIII, not Pius XII


catholicCan You Answer to My Eight Objections to the Third Secret Text?
Yes, here are the answers





Questions  |  Comments  |  Objections  |  Home  |  Books  |  CDs  |  Search  |  Contact Us  |  Donate

Tradition in Action
© 2002-   Tradition in Action, Inc.    All Rights Reserved